Your Company Would Fire You Tomorrow. And You Know It.
Staying is easy. That is exactly the problem.
If the business needed to cut costs next quarter, your name would go on a spreadsheet. Someone you have never met would look at a number next to your name, weigh it against a budget line, and make a decision. No conversation. No consideration for the five years you put in. No credit for the time you stayed late to fix production on a Friday night. Just a calendar invite titled “quick chat” and a box to hand your laptop back.
That is the relationship. That is what loyalty actually gets you.
And while that spreadsheet is being built, someone who joined your team three months ago, who still does not know how half the system works, is probably earning more than you.
This week’s newsletter is brought to you by EM Accelerator.
Most engineering managers are thrown into the role and left to figure it out alone. No training. No community. No one to ask. EM Accelerator is premium training built around everything you actually need. 7 self-paced modules, a private community, monthly office hours, direct access to me, expert interviews, worksheets, and lifetime updates. Everything in one place. Free to join the waitlist at emaccelerator.com.
The psychological contract that does not exist
Most engineers operate under an unspoken assumption: if I stay, work hard, and deliver consistently, the company will take care of me. Promotions will come. Pay will keep up. Loyalty will be recognised and rewarded.
This assumption is wrong.
Companies do not think about loyalty the way employees do. When budgets get cut, tenure does not save you. When redundancies come, the spreadsheet does not have a column for “has been here the longest and really cares.” The relationship you think you have with your employer is not the relationship they think they have with you.
This is not cynical. It is just how businesses work. The sooner you understand that, the sooner you start making career decisions based on reality rather than a contract that was never written down.
The salary trap
Internal pay rises almost never keep pace with the market. A 3% annual raise feels like a reward until you realise the market has moved 15% in two years. The gap between what you earn and what you could earn elsewhere widens silently, year after year.
Your company knows this. They know that internal rises are cheaper than market rate offers. They are banking on the fact that you will not leave. That the comfort of familiarity and the fear of the unknown will keep you in place. For most people, they are right.
Free “Am I Staying For The Right Reasons?” Worksheet for Paid Subscribers
I’ve created a Career Loyalty Self-Audit Worksheet for paid subscribers. It’s a simple, honest tool with:
✅ 7 questions drawn directly from the traps covered in this article
✅ Space to answer honestly without anyone else seeing
✅ A reflection prompt to help you figure out whether you are staying on purpose or staying by default
✅ The one question most engineers avoid asking themselves out loud
If any part of this article made you uncomfortable, this worksheet is worth 10 minutes of honesty with yourself. Most people never do it, and then wonder why they woke up five years later in the same seat.
👉 Subscribe and get the worksheet
The comfort trap
You know the codebase. You know the people. You know how decisions get made and how to navigate the organisation without thinking about it. That familiarity feels like an asset.
It is not. It is the thing keeping you stuck.
Comfort and growth rarely exist in the same place at the same time. When everything is familiar, nothing is challenging. When nothing is challenging, you stop improving. And when you stop improving, your value in the market starts to decline even though your value inside the building feels stable.
The dangerous part is that this happens slowly. There is no single moment where you cross from “I am comfortable and productive” to “I have been standing still for two years.” It just drifts.
The identity lock-in
After several years at one company, your professional identity becomes entangled with it. Your network is mostly internal. Your reputation exists inside the building but not outside it.
Ask yourself this: if your company disappeared tomorrow, how visible would you be in the market? How many people outside the organisation know your name, your work, your track record? For a lot of long-tenure engineers, the honest answer is uncomfortable.
The skills gap you do not see forming
Every company has its own stack, its own processes, its own definition of good engineering. The longer you are there, the more you normalise it. You stop noticing that your technical breadth has narrowed. You stop noticing that the tools and practices you use every day are not universal. You stop noticing that you have not interviewed in years and the thought of it fills you with dread.
The market keeps moving. If you are only exposed to how one company does things, your understanding of the industry slowly shrinks to the size of your building.
The moment of realisation
For most people it is triggered by something external. A recruiter call that goes surprisingly well. A friend at another company describing a culture that sounds completely different. A redundancy round that reminds you the relationship was never as secure as it felt.
Or sometimes it is smaller. A promotion cycle that passes without explanation. A conversation with a newer colleague where you discover they earn more than you for less responsibility.
Most people who have stayed somewhere too long can point to a specific moment when they knew. The problem is that knowing and acting are two different things.
When staying is genuinely the right call
This article is not anti-loyalty. Some companies are exceptional. Some engineers find exactly the right environment and grow consistently for a decade without needing to leave.
The difference is intentionality. Staying because you have made a clear-eyed decision that this place is still growing you, still paying you fairly, and still aligned with where you want to go is a strong career move. Staying because you have not updated your CV in four years and interviewing makes you feel sick is not loyalty. That is fear dressed up as commitment.
Final Thoughts
You do not owe your company loyalty. You owe yourself honesty. The best engineers treat their career like something they actively manage, not something that happens to them while they sit in the same chair year after year. If you are staying, stay on purpose. If you are uncomfortable with the questions this article raises, that discomfort is telling you something. Listen to it before someone else makes the decision for you.
Liked this, even a tiny bit or feel sorry for me? Make sure to click the like button ❤.
Think someone else might find this useful or you just want to make fun of me together? Make sure to share this post 🔗.
Want to write a guest post for this newsletter? Let me know!
The FREE waitlist for my new premium training for Engineering Managers is now live.
I’ve launched a new YouTube channel.
Check me out on LinkedIn. I’m at >58,000 followers now.