Your Team Is About to Lose Its Best Engineer
Most engineers decide to quit long before they tell anyone. Here is what to watch for.
Someone on your team is interviewing right now.
They were in a stand-up this morning. They merged a PR this afternoon. And sometime this week they have a final round interview at another company.
You have no idea.
This is how it almost always goes. The resignation letter feels like it comes out of nowhere, but the decision was made months ago. The CV was updated, the interviews were done, and they had mentally moved on long before anyone noticed. The letter is just admin.
The signals were there. They usually are. Most people just do not know what to look for.
This week’s newsletter is brought to you by EM Accelerator.
If you’re navigating the move into engineering leadership, EM Accelerator is the practical training built specifically for engineering managers who want to stop figuring it out alone. 7 modules, real frameworks, community access, and direct access to me. Join 110+ engineering leaders already on the completely free waitlist at emaccelerator.com.
They stop investing in outcomes
Good engineers care about the result, not just the task. They push back on decisions they think are wrong, flag risks before they become problems, and have opinions about how things should be done.
But this does not only show up in naturally loud people. For vocal engineers, disengagement looks like silence where there used to be challenge. For quieter engineers, it shows up differently: shorter PR descriptions, less async input, fewer contributions in planning docs or design discussions. The common thread is not volume, it is a shift from their own baseline. Someone who always left thorough code review comments and suddenly stops. Someone who used to drop detailed thoughts in Slack threads and now just reacts with a thumbs up.
Pushback requires caring. When someone stops investing in outcomes, it is often because they do not expect to be around for them.
They stop talking about the future
Listen to how people talk about upcoming work. Engaged engineers insert themselves into future plans. They say things like “when we ship this in Q3” or “I want to own that project when it comes up.” They are thinking ahead because they expect to be there.
When someone becomes vague about anything beyond the current sprint, when they stop volunteering for future work or go quiet in roadmap conversations, that is worth noticing. They may not be planning to be around for it.
They stop treating the work like a craft
Strong engineers care about quality. Not in a perfectionist way that blocks shipping, but in the way that means they stay curious, push for the better solution, and care whether the thing they built was actually good.
When that changes, it is noticeable. They start doing the minimum viable version of everything. PR’s that are functional but lack the thoughtfulness you would expect from them. Problems they would previously have dug into that they now just close out quickly. They are still doing the job. But the craft has gone. And when an engineer stops caring about the quality of their own work, something has already broken.
Why it gets missed
Strong engineers do not make it obvious. They keep delivering, keep showing up, keep doing what is expected of them right up until the day they hand in their notice. There is rarely drama, rarely a confrontation, rarely a moment that feels like a clear warning sign.
Teams are also busy. When nothing is visibly on fire, there is no obvious reason to dig deeper. The assumption is that no news is good news, and for a while with a strong engineer, that assumption holds up.
By the time the resignation lands, most people feel blindsided. But in hindsight, the signals were usually there.
Free "Is This Me?" Self-Reflection Worksheet for Paid Subscribers
I've created a Self-Reflection Worksheet for paid subscribers. It's a simple, honest tool with:
✅ 7 questions drawn directly from the warning signs in this article, turned inward
✅ Space to answer honestly without scoring or judgment
✅ A reflection prompt to help you figure out whether what you are feeling means it is time to leave, or time to have a conversation
✅ A final question most engineers never ask themselves out loud
If any part of this article made you think "wait, is this me?" or you are just curious, this worksheet is worth 10 minutes of honest self-reflection. Most people ignore that feeling until the decision makes itself.
👉 Subscribe and get the worksheet
Exit interviews do not tell you the truth
When someone finally sits down for an exit interview, they are not being fully honest. Not because they are dishonest people, but because they are professionals who do not want to burn bridges. They are leaving, and they still need references, still work in the same industry, still might cross paths with these people again.
So they say it was the money. Or a great opportunity they could not turn down. Both of which might be partially true. Neither of which is usually the whole story.
The real reasons tend to run deeper.
The moment trust breaks
Early in my career as a senior engineer, a new hire casually mentioned their starting salary in conversation. They were joining on more than I had worked my way up to over several years.
It was not a huge number. But in that moment something shifted.
It was not really about the money. It was about what the money said: that my years of contribution, context, and loyalty were worth less to the company than someone fresh off the market. That feeling of being disrespected, of trust quietly cracking, is something a belated pay rise rarely fixes. Once it sets in, it has a habit of staying.
This is what people do not say in exit interviews. Not “I was offered more elsewhere.” But “I found out what I was actually worth to this place, and it changed how I saw everything.”
What else drives it
Feeling unchallenged is one of the most common reasons strong engineers leave. They need hard problems. When the work becomes routine and there is nothing left to learn, the job becomes a slow drain rather than a source of energy.
Progression that feels opaque or stalled is another. If someone cannot see a clear path forward, or watches others get recognised while their own contributions go unacknowledged, they start asking why they are putting in the effort.
And finally, a loss of belief. In the product, the leadership, the direction of the company. When someone stops believing the thing they are building matters, it is very hard to get that back.
What to do about it
Once the signals are there, there is still a window. Not a huge one, but a window.
Ignoring it and hoping things improve rarely works. But a clumsy conversation that puts someone on the spot can make things worse.
What tends to work is something direct but low pressure. Not “are you thinking of leaving?” but something more like “I want to make sure this place is still working for you. What would make the next six months genuinely good?”
Then the harder part: act on what they say. One conversation where nothing changes does not help. It often accelerates the decision, because now they have said what they need and watched it go nowhere.
You cannot reach someone who has already fully checked out. The goal is to have this conversation before that point, when it can still change something.
Final Thoughts
The best engineers always have options. They stay because the work is interesting, the team is good, and they believe in what they are building.
When those things erode, they leave. Quietly, professionally, and with far less warning than anyone would like.
The teams that hold onto strong engineers over the long term are not the ones with the best counter-offers. They are the ones who noticed something was off, asked the right questions, and actually did something about the answers.
Someone on your team is interviewing right now. The question is whether you will notice before it is too late.
Liked this, even a tiny bit or feel sorry for me? Make sure to click the like button ❤.
Think someone else might find this useful or you just want to make fun of me together? Make sure to share this post 🔗.
Want to write a guest post for this newsletter? Let me know!
The FREE waitlist for my new premium training for Engineering Managers is now live.
I’ve launched a new YouTube channel.
Check me out on LinkedIn. I’m at >58,000 followers now.